Microsoft Ordered to Delete Browser

Posted: Saturday, January 17, 2009 by El Guru in Browsers, IE, Microsoft, Other, Windows

From the Associated Press/NewYorkTimes.com:

BRUSSELS (AP) — The European Union said Friday that Microsoft’s practice of selling the Internet Explorer browser together with its Windows operating system violated the union’s antitrust rules.

It ordered the software giant to untie the browser from its operating system in the 27-nation union, enabling makers of rival browsers to compete fairly.

“Microsoft’s tying of Internet Explorer to the Windows operating system harms competition between Web browsers, undermines product innovation and ultimately reduces consumer choice,” the E.U. said in a statement.


I find this a little extreme. First off, Microsoft is not “selling” the Internet Explorer browser. It is either included with Windows or can be downloaded for free. It is not like Microsoft is getting any monetary benefit or the others such as Chrome, Safari and Opera are losing any money.

How is this going to enable rival browser makers to “compete fairly”? I could see this back firing big time. Consider this, how do get a web browser on your machine? You use the pre-loaded Internet Explorer and download the browser of your choice. Oh wait, Internet Explorer can no longer be pre-loaded. Now Microsoft and these other browser makers need to spend money to make install CDs and the associated packaging. Well, they would be creating jobs at least. So after you purchase your Windows PC you need to pick-up an install CD for the web browser of your choice. While I am sure Microsoft could  afford to either sell the install CD very cheap or even give it away. But the others wouldn’t be able to compete and would have to stop making install CDs. So much for that idea. I suppose a program can be written that will run the first time the user run Windows they can choose which browser to install.

But wait there’s more! Why does Microsoft have to ‘untie’ Internet Explorer from Windows and yet Apple can keep “selling” Safari with Mac OS X? A bit of a double standard here if you ask me. How does Apple/Safari NOT violate the union’s antitrust rules? Macs can run Firefox, Opera, Chrome and yes even Internet Exploiter (why in the world any would want to is beyond me).

Edit: Someone in another forum pointed out that may be the EU wants Microsoft to make it possible to remove Internet Explorer. Which makes sense in the “tying of Internet Explorer to the Windows operating system” part, but not the “Practice of selling the Internet Explorer browser together with its Windows operating system”. Still you can run other browsers even if you can not remove Internet Explorer.

Comments
  1. Captain Canuck says:

    Conclusion: Both Micosoft and Apple suck.
    Go Linux. QED

  2. A.Y. Siu says:

    It would mean the OEMs would sell Windows preinstalled with Firefox, Opera, or some other browser and be able to remove Internet Explorer completely.

    In Mac OS X, you can actually delete Safari quite easily.

    In any case, who says Apple is off the hook? They could very well have antitrust suits against them soon, too.

  3. Ver Noss says:

    It’s quite clear that more people are using IE due to it being bundled with Windows. Few would download and use IE if you had to do it manually — like with the other browser. Therefore, Microsoft is skewing the market.

    This wouldn’t have been less of an issue if their browser acutally followed web standards. However, Microsoft has been ignoring web standards for years, only making very slow progress when forced.

    The biggest imapact of this case may be that Microsoft is finally forced to ship a standards-based browser. No tricks, no gimmicke, no “but only in this and that mode”.

  4. […] Firefox Extension Guru’s Blog has an article where he gives some thoughts on the European Union order to untie Internet Explorer from Windows. […]

  5. Rick says:

    “Consider this, how do get a web browser on your machine? You use the pre-loaded Internet Explorer and download the browser of your choice. Oh wait, Internet Explorer can no longer be pre-loaded.”

    No. You include a minimal FTP client, put several icons on the default desktop, and download the browser of your choice.

    If this happens, IE8 will not be the majority browser on windows 7.

  6. the simurgh says:

    all they have to do is pick a third party browser install it like they used to do netscape to escape from this type of trouble and their good.

  7. […] have discussed this back in January when Microsoft Ordered to Delete Browser EC Principle 4: Microsoft’s financial and other incentives to distributors must be […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s